- ancient mailing list + proper u-boot mailing list.

M

On 14.7.2018 00:34, Grant Likely wrote:

I'm pleased to announce the release of version 0.6 of the Embedded Base Boot Requirements (EBBR) specification.

https://github.com/ARM-software/ebbr/releases/tag/v0.6

EBBR is a new specification defining a standard boot environment suitable for full feature operating systems running on embedded platforms...

Well, it will when it's finished.

It is well know that firmware for embedded systems is a fragmented area with each platform behaving in subtly incompatible ways. It is also completely different from the firmware interface used on general purpose desktops and servers. For OSes, this makes supporting more than a handful of platforms a nearly impossible affair. EBBR aims to solve this problem by defining a standard boot interface that can easily be implemented using either U-Boot or Tianocore, and is based on the same UEFI specification used on general purpose computers.

By adopting EBBR, platform vendors can reduce the amount of engineering effort required to support their products and make them easier to use. As EBBR is being developed in conjunction with the U-Boot, Tianocore, and Trusted Firmware projects, most of the functionality required is already implemented and ready to be used if one uses an up to date release of U-Boot or Tianocore.

For OS vendors, this makes far easier to support embedded platforms because they don't need to tailor the boot process for each platform. The same boot infrastructure works on both desktop/servers and on EBBR compliant embedded platforms.

And finally, for end users, working with an EBBR compliant platform means they can boot the OS of their choice without needing to learn low level details of the platform firmware.

This v0.6 release of EBBR is a pre-release document. The contents are not final. The purpose of this release is to raise awareness of the EBBR project, and to solicit feedback on the current draft. Please do read and provide comments on the boot-architecture@lists.linaro.org mailing list.

The plan is to release v1.0 before the end of the 2018.

Thanks to the EBBR committee members who contributed to this release:

Andreas Färber (SUSE)   Alex Graf (SUSE)   Ryan Harkin (Linaro)   Rob Herring (Linaro)   Udit Kumar (NXP)   Leif Lindholm (Linaro)   Bill Mills (TI)   Peter Robinson (Red Hat)   Tom Rini (Konsulko)   Daniel Thompson (Linaro)   Dong Wei (Arm)

Sincerely, Grant Likely, EBBR committee co-chair

Note on U-Boot implementations

It is expected that EBBR compliant can be achieved by using a recent version of U-Boot with the appropriate configuration options. An implementers guide for U-Boot will be written before EBBR v1.0 is released.

There is also work ongoing to get the UEFI Self Certification Test running on U-Boot. Once working, this will be a tool for vendors to test their platforms for EBBR compliance.

FAQ

1. Does EBBR define a new interface?

No. EBBR builds on the existing UEFI spec by requiring a specific subset that can be implemented today using U-Boot, and either Devicetree or ACPI.

2. Does EBBR require Devicetree? ACPI?

EBBR allows platforms to provide either ACPI or Devicetree. Linux supports both system description languages equally well, and Devicetree is in common use on embedded platforms. As long as the platform supplies a system description that can boot a mainline operating system.

EBBR does not attempt to define a common base standard for Devicetree platforms because of the wide variety of platforms needed to be supported. The one assumption EBBR does make is that the target operating system already has support for the SoC on the platform.

3. Is EBBR only for U-Boot and Linux embedded systems?

No. While U-Boot+Linux platforms were certainly the primary audience when EBBR was first conceived, the spec is very purposefully written to be OS-independent. EBBR requires specific interfaces, but those interface can be implemented by any firmware project.

We would absolutely like to have review, feedback and contributions from non-Linux, non-U-Boot users.

4. Can I contribute to the EBBR specification?

Yes. The EBBR source document is on GitHub, and we use the boot-architecture@lists.linaro.org mailing list.

https://github.com/ARM-Software/ebbr _______________________________________________ Arm.ebbr-discuss mailing list Arm.ebbr-discuss@arm.com