RE: [U-Boot-Users] [PATCH] Compact Flash + TI PCI1510 support for MPC8540ADS board

Wolfgang,
First some formal reasons:
- CHANGELOG entry missing
- Coding Style violations (trailing white space, wrong
indentation, etc.)
I'll correct that.
- You add a cople of new config options (like
CONFIG_IDE_CARDBUS_CF_16BIT) without any documentation.
I needed a config option for the compact flash being interfaced on a cardbus in a legacy 16-bit mode. Have grep'ed the U-Boot sources and couldn't find anything that would work. I'll need to document that option.
Technical reasons:
I think your changes to drivers/ti_pci1410a.c might have impact on (read: will break) existing board support that uses this driver. Did you check this with the previous authors?
You change the default configuration of the MPC8540ADS board; did you check this with the maintainer of this board?
I'll try to contact the previous authors and consult with them a possible resolution that wouldn't break any existing configurations. My PCI1410/1510 related changes are based on the recommendations I've received from the TI FAE. The compact flash related changes are based on the data provided by SanDisk and SimpleTech FAEs.
I certainly appreciate your feedback. Regards,
Adam Zajac

Dear Adam,
in message EFB813091B18D511BD3600508B644F8214DC76D8@tx14exm06.ftw.mot.com you wrote:
- CHANGELOG entry missing
- Coding Style violations (trailing white space, wrong
indentation, etc.)
I'll correct that.
Thanks. Please provide new patch against top of CVS (which is a moving target), and/or discuss with Jon Loeliger if you can/want to use git.
anything that would work. I'll need to document that option.
Yes, please.
I'll try to contact the previous authors and consult with them a possible
They were / are on Cc:
I certainly appreciate your feedback.
You are welcome.
Best regards,
Wolfgang Denk
participants (2)
-
Wolfgang Denk
-
Zajac Adam-AAZ004