On Wed, 2019-05-08 at 13:43 -0500, dannenberg@ti.com wrote:
Hi TF, thanks for chiming in. Comments inlined...
On Wed, May 08, 2019 at 04:31:35AM +0000, Chee, Tien Fong wrote:
On Tue, 2019-05-07 at 22:00 +0200, Simon Goldschmidt wrote:
On 07.05.19 19:25, Andreas Dannenberg wrote:
[...]
While I also have a working solution based on the existing FS loader framework this has its own challenges, namely by its very nature only addressing a subset of our use cases (no eMMC/SD RAW boot support for example),
IMO, it's actually not that hard to enhance RAW support, i think minimal changes are required. I have attached the patches about an example of loading RAW from QSPI that i have done locally last few week ago.
As your patches show, no it's not hard, it's more or less taking pieces from the SPL loader framework and refactoring them into the FS loader, creating a good and universal solution usable across SPL and U-Boot in environments that are not tightly constrained in terms of memory.
What I was going after is finding a way to load from different media "pre-relocation" SPL (board_init_f), with almost no memory available, where I have to agonize over every single KB available.
This is just a simple "loader", provide user flexibility of loading stuff in anywhere, from SPL to U-Boot. As long as DM is supported by the time running at "pre-relocation" SPL, then FS loader should be able to work.
being heavier on resource usage (needing to use ENV to pass parameters),
ENV is optional, you can use DTS.
Is it? I had to update the FS loader framework when I experimented with it, please see attached patch. I had refactored it such that I can pass in all relevant data via platform data for the intial boot mode I was going after, so that I can dynamically configure it on the fly from early SPL board_init_f() based on boot media / boot mode, etc.
Yes, you can tie up loader with target HW node for destination loading. For example, tie up with FPGA manager node, loading bistream file from MMC to FPGA manager.
Here is an example, but i put the fs loader phandle under chosen node because most files and images are stored in the same storage. http://git.denx.de/?p=u-boot/u-boot-socfpga.git;a=commit;h=0a42a132a4b8 46031df2c4a7d04692240ed34843
For example loading FPGA bitstream from QSPI RAW:
/* DTS */ / {
- aliases {
spi0 = &qspi;- };
- fs_loader0: fs-loader {
u-boot,dm-pre-reloc;compatible = "u-boot,fs-loader";sfconfig = <0 0 100000000 3>;- };
+};
+&fpga_mgr {
- u-boot,dm-pre-reloc;
- firmware-loader = <&fs_loader0>;
- altr,bitstream = "300000";
+};
The above hard-codes and duplicates information that is already known to U-Boot (CONFIG_SF_DEFAULT_*), and will do more of the same as this is being extended. How does one keep this consistent?
Current fs loader not support RAW loading yet, i'm not sure whether it should support it by adding more specific storage API(much more messy), or just fully support filesystem only with one generic filesystem abstract interface.
This example codes provide user opportunity to override the spi setting when running fs loader. CONFIG_SF_DEFAULT_* would be used by the drivers which are not running the fs loader.
And how does this scale to support like 5 different boot modes using a single DTB? I guess one could populate 5 nodes, and then pick one based on boot mode during SPL execution, by extending the probe function accordingly.
This is just a very simple fs loader. This is totally up to user how they want to scale it up, may be adding the function to populate the fs loader nodes, or loading the images based on boot storages ordering in DTS?
and not addressing the need to probe the boot peripheral.
You can add more different probing method in function called "fs_loader_probe". Current fs_loader supports block(sdmmc, emmc, etc...) probing, and with the patches attached support QSPI probing.
Another idea come to mind, we can use fs_loader for loading FIT boot image into RAM, and boot from RAM with existing SPL loader framework, but i'm not sure this implementation fit to your use case?
Unfortunately for what I'm working on there is no space for this. It would be nice to be able to load our "System Firmware" alongside the next stage of U-Boot in a single FIT, and then just extact that firmware image similar to what CONFIG_SPL_FPGA_SUPPORT does in spl_fit.c. However I must load SYSFW and the U-Boot next stage as two steps (while bringing up DDR in-between....).
As I tried to explain in my earlier email to Simon, I almost see the minimally-intrusive extensions I did to the SPL loader framework via "spl: Make image loader infrastructure more universal" and the FS loader framework to be elements that are orthogonal and can both exist. Maybe FS loader can partially build upon the SPL loader foundation as well?
Yes, fs loader can be in anywhere, it can be part of SPL loader framework as well. It can be as complement to SPL loader also.
Thanks.
TF.
-- Andreas Dannenberg Texas Instruments Inc
This particular framework works well for use cases requiring to load firmware from FS-based media once DDR is up and U-Boot is in a more "initialized" state but it is not a one-fits all solution for very early use in SPL board_init_f() accross different boot modes.
And would it be an option to improve the loader (maybe dropping the "fs" from its name)? I think it's an "fs" loader because its idea has been copied from Linux. I think in U-Boot, it's more common to have things at a raw offset instead of a file system. Just thinking...
Current fs_loader only support filesystem, and i agree that it made sense to remove the "fs" once it supports the RAW offset as well.
Thanks.
Regards, TF
And the current state of that fs_loader is like it is because it fits its single user (socfpga stratix 10), I think.
Anyway, even if you do need yet another loader, would it make sense to create a common file instead of adding this in your arch/mach?
Regards, Simon
Andreas Dannenberg (10): mmc: k3_arasan: Allow driver to probe without PDs specified spl: Allow skipping clearing BSS during relocation spl: Make image loader infrastructure more universal arm: K3: Introduce System Firmware loader framework armV7R: K3: am654: Allow using SPL BSS pre-relocation armv7R: K3: am654: Use full malloc implementation in SPL armV7R: K3: am654: Load SYSFW binary and config from boot media configs: am65x_evm_r5: All sysfw to be loaded via MMC configs: am65x_hs_evm_r5: All sysfw to be loaded via MMC configs: am65x_hs_evm: Add Support for eMMC boot
Faiz Abbas (2): configs: am65x_evm: Add Support for eMMC boot am65x: README: Add eMMC layout and flash instructions
Lokesh Vutla (1): armv7R: dts: k3: am654: Update mmc nodes for loading sysfw
arch/arm/dts/k3-am654-r5-base-board.dts | 18 ++ arch/arm/lib/crt0.S | 3 + arch/arm/mach-k3/Kconfig | 40 +++ arch/arm/mach-k3/Makefile | 1 + arch/arm/mach-k3/am6_init.c | 34 ++- arch/arm/mach-k3/include/mach/sysfw-loader.h | 12 + arch/arm/mach-k3/sysfw-loader.c | 263 +++++++++++++++++++ board/ti/am65x/Kconfig | 1 + board/ti/am65x/README | 52 ++++ common/spl/Kconfig | 13 + common/spl/spl_fit.c | 14 + common/spl/spl_mmc.c | 76 ++++-- configs/am65x_evm_a53_defconfig | 2 + configs/am65x_evm_r5_defconfig | 7 +- configs/am65x_hs_evm_a53_defconfig | 2 + configs/am65x_hs_evm_r5_defconfig | 7 +- drivers/mmc/k3_arsan_sdhci.c | 16 +- include/configs/am65x_evm.h | 30 ++- include/spl.h | 26 ++ 19 files changed, 577 insertions(+), 40 deletions(-) create mode 100644 arch/arm/mach-k3/include/mach/sysfw- loader.h create mode 100644 arch/arm/mach-k3/sysfw-loader.c