On 02/03/2019 07:32 PM, Heinrich Schuchardt wrote:
Hello Alex, hello Takahiro,
this morning I met Daniel Thompson of Linaro. He thinks it would be quite valuable if U-Boot would at least offer read access to EFI variables at runtime.
I think what it takes is only a RAM buffer that we put between our current storage backend (i.e. synchronization with U-Boot variables) and the API implementation.
We will need such a buffer anyway for non-permanent variables once we have a SPI flash storage.
I think slowly we need to take a critical design decision: Do we want to be in the business of managing runtime UEFI variables?
I don't have a fully cohesive answer to that yet. My gut feeling tells me, that runtime variables would be much better off if they lived in TrustZone. That way we don't have to play relocation tricks, and devices that give you persistency are owned by the secure world anyway, so there is no weird intersection between OS and RTS.
So maybe the path forward would be to implement variable services in ATF (or OP-TEE rather I suppose) and just provide shim stubs to communicate with them from runtime services? That would keep all the variable logic platform agnostic, and we would not have to jump through weird hoops with DM.
Alex