Hi Tom
On Wed, 31 Jul 2024 at 20:17, Tom Rini trini@konsulko.com wrote:
On Wed, Jul 31, 2024 at 08:39:23AM -0600, Simon Glass wrote:
[snip]
so that step three can be seeing what tweaks may be needed in where things allocate memory.
So my series is step 3?
Or at least understanding what the problems may still be, yes.
In that case I would like to clean up EFI's memory management before doing step 2, since I believe many of the problems will just go away if we can get that right.
Well, I think that's where some of the big points of contention are, yes. You say "fix" and Ilias and Heinrich say "but the spec".
Using malloc on efi_allocate_pool() would be ok spec-wise. Simon's current patch is ignoring the efi memory type metadata we have to preserve. On top of that using malloc for a *single* memory type, just kicks the can down the road until an EFI app chooses a different type and we are back to the same problem.
It's fine to teach efi_allocate_pool to use malloc with 2 conditions - memory types are preserved for all allocations - malloc area is big enough
Cheers /Ilias
Perhaps once step one is done it will be easier to find a way to address your concerns without also breaking "the spec".
-- Tom